The Growth in Independents…Is Not

As our previous research has indicated, Independents, with leaners included, constitute a growing portion of the electorate.  The real story about the growth of Independents, though, is more nuanced and complex.

First, in our recent look at party identification over time, we made a chart showing the drop in party identification (excluding leaners) over the decades by looking at party identification in January of each year:

chart 1

Of course, it is possible to flip this around and look at it from the reverse – the growth of Independents over the decades (including leaners):

chart 2

Underlying this finding, though, is that “hard Independents” have been stable during this time period.

chart 3

The drop in party identification is simply people moving from strong/not-so-strong partisanship to a so-called Independent, while more than half of these initial Independents are actually partisans in disguise.  (As a point of reference, across Wirthlin tracking in the 1980s, hard Independents ranged typically from 9{09f965da52dc6ab4c1643a77bd40d1f729d807040cd8db540234bb981a782222} to 14{09f965da52dc6ab4c1643a77bd40d1f729d807040cd8db540234bb981a782222}.  The growth of hard Independents was fueled by the economic and political discontent in late 1991/1992 and has generally been stuck in the upper-teens since that time.)

The fact that Independents who say they lean toward either the Republican or Democratic Party are “partisans in disguise” is why in the NBC/WSJ survey we have used “hard Independents” when using the term Independent.

Here is a key table that looks at President Obama’s feeling thermometer and Congressional Preference by party identification among registered voters in 2014.  There is one clear conclusion across the data below: how much Independents who lean Republican or Democrat mirror the attitudinal views of their not-so-strong partisan counterparts.

chart 4

For more comparison data, see the end of the blog post for tables which compare key political attitudes and then key demographic variables on a seven point party identification scale (strong Democrat, not-so-strong Democrat, Independent/lean Democrat, hard Independent, Independent/lean Republican, not-so-strong Republican, and strong Republican).

In fact, on the Republican side, the Independents/lean Republicans are even more likely to say they are Tea Party supporters and have a positive view of the Tea Party.

chart 5

Amidst all this similarity though, there is one difference:  The Independent leaners are less likely to have a positive view of the party to which they lean than the not-so-strong partisans.  In this way, we find one clue at least about what distinguishes a not-so-strong partisan from an Independent who leans toward a party.

chart 6

chart 7

While much has been made of the “growth” of Independents, it is clear when looking at the data the growth is coming from soft partisans saying they are Independents rather than any increase over the past generation in the number of hard Independents.

 chart 8

Similar Articles

  • Americans See China And Russia As Adversaries Posing Two Different Threats
    read more

  • A New Look At Ideology
    read more

  • Is social media your friend or a frenemy?
    read more

  • Trump’s numbers tied for his peak high as impeachment talk looms
    read more

  • Independents Key to Trump Approval Boost
    read more

Public Opinion Strategies helped us to clarify what we wanted to learn and then conducted research and analysis that shed light even beyond the questions we set out to ask. They were very receptive to our suggestions, responsive to our queries, and flexible when we needed them to be.

Public Opinion Strategies has consistently offered unparalleled advice and spot-on polling that has shaped how and where we spent money and deploy key resources. Additionally, they have always been an excellent steward of limited campaign resources, ensuring we spend wisely and not a dollar more than necessary in order to get the information we need.

Robert Blizzard and Public Opinion Strategies did a great job for us throughout our successful campaign for Congress. Robert gave us accurate data, spot on analysis, and professional advice, all of which were essential to our victory.

Public Opinion Strategies is one of our go-to pollsters when it comes to testing public support for bond ballot measures and other initiative proposals. They are available to provide ongoing consultation with regard to crafting of ballot questions, public outreach messaging, and related efforts.

ACLI has worked with Public Opinion Strategies for decades, through several tough industry battles—often ones in which public opinion does not naturally fall on the side of insurers. Yet Bill and his team consistently provide invaluable strategic advice by refining our messages and helping us frame our issues in a way that makes them understandable and persuasive.

The data from Public Opinion Strategies provided important insight and informed our public awareness campaign. We sincerely appreciate their professionalism and expertise in this arena.

Nicole McCleskey and the team at Public Opinion Strategies have been invaluable to me, both during my campaigns and as Governor of the State of New Mexico. It’s not just the accuracy of their numbers, but guiding the overall strategy that makes them so valuable.

Public Opinion Strategies has been a part of our team in Missouri for more than a decade. With their data and guidance, Republicans here were able to attain a majority in the House in 2002 for the first time in fifty years, and we have been able to grow that majority to the point that we now have a record, veto-proof majority.

In my tenure at two leading business associations, facing huge and complex consumer issues, I have benefitted enormously from the objective advisory skills of Bill and his team. They do their homework, they are rigorous, dispassionate and thoughtful. Turning questions into answers is a clever tag, but it’s also an apt description of the professional talents of the firm.

I consider Public Opinion Strategies to be a part of our team. That is the way we have always worked. They have helped us to understand our needs and fashioned research solutions to meet those needs. They have helped us to meet killer deadlines by being flexible, executing rapidly, and insuring quality. Teamwork is the best way to describe it.

Accuracy, speed, and deep knowledge of key issues and public sentiment are the hallmarks of quality opinion research, and on these measures Public Opinion Strategies consistently delivers. I have had the pleasure of working with Public Opinion Strategies for more than 15 years on dozens of issues, and they are undoubtedly the gold standard.

Public Opinion Strategies’ track record of success and wealth of experience in political campaigns and issue advocacy are why they are one of the most trusted and well respected public opinion firms in Washington, D.C. Their insights and perspectives have helped to inform a wide array of public affairs activities across multiple industries.